1912 $5 Indian PCGS MS63 CAC. This is a really striking example of more commonly encountered year for the $5 Indian. Certainly not as common in Choice Mint State as the 1909-D (10,263 PCGS coins graded in MS63), the 1912 appears much less seldom. Total PCGS graded MS63 is 1,459 as of this writing. Total CAC endorsed MS63 1912 $5’s equal 106 or less than 10%. For the money, it’s best to buy the slightly uncommon coins for close to or at the common date price.