1912 $5 Indian PCGS MS64 CAC. We acquired a couple of coins from within the European community last month and this 1912 $5 Indian is one of them. The 1912 year is a “slightly uncommon” date while the 1909-D is absolutely the most common. The total PCGS graded MS64 is 459 as of this writing. Total CAC endorsed MS64 coins is 64. We note a couple of non-CAC 1912 $5 Indians sold at public auction by Heritage in September this year (2016) for $4,935 and $4,230. The PCGS published Price Guide price is $2,100.